When faced with pain or injury, surgery can seem like the most definitive solution. However, for many musculoskeletal conditions, physical therapy (PT) can be just as effective—without the risks, costs, and downtime associated with surgery. In fact, physical therapy should often be the first line of treatment before considering invasive options.
1. Comparable Outcomes Without the Risks
Studies have shown that physical therapy can provide similar outcomes to surgery for conditions like:
-
Meniscal tears and knee osteoarthritis
A landmark study in The New England Journal of Medicine (2013) found no significant difference in functional improvement between patients who had surgery and those who underwent PT alone (NEJM Study). -
Lumbar spinal stenosis and herniated discs
Research published in Annals of Internal Medicine (2015) demonstrated that physical therapy was as effective as surgery in improving symptoms of lumbar spinal stenosis (Annals Study). -
Rotator cuff tears
Non-surgical management, including physical therapy, has been shown to relieve pain and improve function, particularly for partial-thickness tears (British Journal of Sports Medicine).
2. Lower Cost and Faster Recovery
Surgery is expensive, and recovery can take weeks or months. Physical therapy, on the other hand, is:
-
More affordable
-
Less risky (no infection or anesthesia complications)
-
Minimally disruptive to your daily life
3. Addresses Root Cause, Not Just Symptoms
PT focuses on:
-
Improving joint and muscle function
-
Correcting faulty movement patterns
-
Strengthening weak areas to prevent recurrence of injury
Surgery often fixes the structural issue but doesn’t address the movement dysfunction that caused it in the first place.
4. Personalized, Whole-Body Care
Physical therapists evaluate the whole body, not just the injured part. This holistic approach improves mobility, function, and overall well-being—empowering patients to take control of their health.
When Is Surgery Still Necessary?
Some situations do require surgery—like complete ligament tears, fractures that won’t heal properly, or severe structural deformities. But for many common orthopedic conditions, physical therapy is a safe, effective, and empowering first step.
Resources for More Information:
-
American Physical Therapy Association (APTA): https://www.choosept.com
-
Mayo Clinic – Physical Therapy Overview: https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/physical-therapy/about/pac-20384594
-
NEJM Knee Surgery vs. PT Study: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1301408
Bottom Line:
If you’re considering surgery for joint or muscle pain, ask your doctor if physical therapy is a viable alternative. In many cases, you can avoid the scalpel—and still get back to doing what you love.
Need help? Contact us to schedule a personalized evaluation with one of our licensed physical therapists.
